2019 AFL Trade and Draft Thread

  • Welcome to Yellow and Black Online. Registered Members gain access to tools and additional Forums designed to enhance your experience.
  • Coterie Membership premium membership package allows the subscriber to enjoy the site without any advertising, access to a private forum, "The Coterie Room" as well as some other extra tools that you can use on the forum.

    Full information can be found here: Member Upgrades. I'll add more benefits as they are requested or as I think of them.

  • ✅ AFL Premiers 2019
    ✅ VFL Premiers 2019
  • Congratulations to Dion Prestia - 2019 Jack Dyer Medal winner


Coach

Staff member
Coach
Foundation Member
Site Immortal
Jul 17, 2003
12,636
135
63
Starting this thread so that we can discuss trades (and possible trades), and all of the drafts.

To start off, Geelong have just announced that Shaun Grigg will join them as a Development Coach for the 2020 season.

The Key dates are:
Friday 4 October - AFL Restricted Free Agency Offer and Unrestricted Free Agency Period Commences.
Monday 7 October 9am - Telstra AFL Trade Period Commences.
Thursday 10 October 5pm - Close of AFL Restricted Free Agency Offer and Unrestricted Free Agency Period.
Sunday 13 October - AFL Restricted Free Agency Matching Offer Three-Day Period Ends.
Wednesday 16 October 7.30pm - Telstra AFL Trade Period Closes (for exchange of players).
Thursday 17 October - Telstra AFL Trade Period Opens (selections only).
Friday 1 November - AFL Delisted Player Free Agency Period (1) Commences
Monday 11 November- AFL Delisted Player Free Agency Period (1) Closes, Out of Contract Listed AFL Primary List Players Draft Nomination Form and Player Request for Removal from List Form Lodged with AFL
Wednesday 13 November - AFL Delisted Player Free Agency Period (2) Commences
Friday 22 November 2pm - Telstra AFL Trade Period Closes (for exchange of selections only); Delisted Primary List Draft Nomination Form Lodgement; Non–Retained Rookie Players Draft Nomination Form Lodgement; Players Not Registered or Played for Three years Rookie List Form Lodgement; New or Expired (after 3 years) Draft Nomination Form Lodgement, AFL Father-Son Bidding Nominations, Final Draft Nomination Form Lodgement.
Friday 22 November 5pm - AFL Delisted Player Free Agency Period (2) Closes
Wednesday 27 November 7pm - 9.30pm - NAB AFL Draft Selection Meeting (Round One), Marvel Stadium.
Thursday 28 November 7pm - 9.30pm - NAB AFL Draft Selection Meeting (Round Two onwards to conclusion).
Friday 29 November 8am – 9am - AFL Delisted Player Free Agency Period (3)
Friday 29 November 10am - NAB AFL Pre-Season and Rookie Draft

Plenty going on over the next couple of months!
 

Vosstiger

Staff member
Assistant Coach
Sep 21, 2008
5,189
76
48
55
Grigg moved to Geelong a few months ago so this was always on the cards
 

Coach

Staff member
Coach
Foundation Member
Site Immortal
Jul 17, 2003
12,636
135
63
Below is the 2019 Free Agency List which includes Restricted, Unrestricted and Delisted Free Agents (currently on Club lists) across the competition as at October 3, 2019..



2019 Restricted Free Agents

Sam Jacobs (Adelaide Crows)
Brandon Ellis (Richmond)

Jack Newnes (St Kilda)

2019 Unrestricted Free Agents
Adelaide Crows

Cameron Ellis-Yolmen (Rookie)*
Paul Hunter (Rookie)*

Brisbane Lions
Ryan Lester*
Ryan Bastinac (Rookie)*

Carlton
Dale Thomas*
Josh Deluca (Rookie)*

Collingwood
Ben Reid
Jamie Elliott
Lynden Dunn*
Tim Broomhead (Rookie)*
Sam Murray (Rookie)*

Essendon
Zac Clarke (Rookie)*
Michael Hartley*
Mitch Brown*
Will Snelling (Rookie)*

Fremantle
Hayden Ballantyne
Ryan Nyhuis (Rookie)*

Geelong Cats
Harry Taylor
Scott Selwood*

Gold Coast SUNS
Tom Nicholls
Jack Leslie (Rookie)*
Brad Scheer (Rookie)*
Harrison Wigg (Rookie)*

GWS GIANTS
Adam Tomlinson
Tom Sheridan*
Dylan Buckley (Rookie)*

Hawthorn
Grant Birchall
Paul Puopolo
Ryan Schoenmakers*
Darren Minchington*
Tim Mohr (Rookie)*

Port Adelaide
Matthew Broadbent
Jack Trengove*
Cameron Sutcliffe (Rookie)*
Cam Hewett (Rookie)*

Richmond
Shane Edwards
Maverick Weller (Rookie)*
Jacob Townsend (Rookie)*

St Kilda
David Armitage
Nathan Brown*
Lewis Pierce (Rookie)*
Sam Rowe (Rookie)*

Sydney Swans
Daniel Menzel*

West Coast Eagles
Chris Masten
Will Schofield
Fraser McInnes (Rookie)*
Keegan Brooksby (Rookie)*
Josh Smith (Rookie)*

Western Bulldogs
Tory Dickson
Fletcher Roberts
Ryan Gardner (Rookie)*
Roarke Smith (Rookie)*

*Previously qualified as a Free Agent
 

amigo

Listed Player
Mar 29, 2009
4,378
64
48
Kingsley and Caracella were key tacticians for our game day setup and tactics. Are they easily replaceable?

If not, why did we release Caracella, who I believe had another year on his contract, to take up another assistant role? If it was a senior role, understandable.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Black

Vosstiger

Staff member
Assistant Coach
Sep 21, 2008
5,189
76
48
55
Getting new Assistant Coaches in prevents staleness. Some are more replaceable than others but I think a constant churning just like that of the playing list is a good thing. Hardwick et al already have their IP someone new may bring something different.
These departing coaches will take some of our IP which is one part of the equation, the second is do the clubs they move to have the appropriate cattle to make it work.
We will continue to evolve for standing still means we will be overtaken
 
  • Like
Reactions: amigo

Coach

Staff member
Coach
Foundation Member
Site Immortal
Jul 17, 2003
12,636
135
63
1. The Gold Coast Football Club made an offer to Restricted Free Agent Brandon Ellis (Richmond) on Friday October 4. The Richmond Football Club elected not to match the offer on Saturday October 5 and Brandon Ellis is now able to join the Gold Coast SUNS immediately.

Based on the player’s age and the contract offer, the AFL advised the Richmond Football Club the club would be eligible for a Round Two compensation selection, which would be number 39 on the current provisional draft selection order.

2. The Brisbane Lions Football Club signed Unrestricted Free Agent Cameron Ellis-Yolmen (Adelaide Crows) on Saturday October 5.

Based on the player’s age and the contract offer, the AFL advised the Adelaide Football Club the club would be eligible for a Round Three compensation selection, which would be number 47 on the current provisional draft selection order.
 

Black

Site Immortal
Jul 10, 2006
11,401
153
63
5
What an absolute joke that is !

What other sport in the world has a secret formula to govern draft selections ?

The secret formula might as well be called the..'we'll hand out draft picks to whoever the f**k we want , without transparency or recourse' formula.

The AFL will have to change it. They can call it The Ellis/Ellis Yolmen/Lycett clause.

Forgetting for a minute that Brandon Ellis is a 2 time premiership player , whilst Ellis -Yolmen is a rookie who's struggled to get a game for most of his career and Lycett has been much the same... consider this >>

B.ELLIS - ....
AGE 26 , YRS PLAYED 8 , GAMES 176 , AVE GAMES 22 AVE DISP 22 , GOALS 56 , DRAFT PICK # 15 COMPO PICK # 39
S. LYCETT
- .AGE 26 , YRS PLAYED 8 , GAMES 75 , ..AVE GAMES 9 , .AVE DISP 7 , .GOALS 45 , DRAFT PICK # 29 COMPO PICK # 20
E-YOLMEN
- AGE 26 , YRS PLAYED 5 , GAMES 39 , ..AVE GAMES 8 , AVE DISP 19 , GOALS 15 , ROOKIE PICK # 31 COMPO PICK # 47
 

Coach

Staff member
Coach
Foundation Member
Site Immortal
Jul 17, 2003
12,636
135
63
Three-way trade: The Geelong Cats trade Tim Kelly, its Round Three Selection (currently number 57) and its Future Round Three Selection to the West Coast Eagles for its Round One Selection (currently number 14), its Round Two Selection (currently number 24), its Round Two Selection (currently number 33) and its Future Round One Selection. The West Coast Eagles trade its Round Three Selection (currently number 57) – on traded from Geelong Cats – to Essendon for its Round Three Selection (currently number 52). The Geelong Cats trade its Round Two Selection (currently number 33) – on traded from the West Coast Eagles – to Essendon for its Round Two Selection (currently number 37).


I really don't get why Essendon was included in this trade. Sure, they received an earlier Round 2 selection but how does that help Geelong or West Coast?

Can someone explain this?
 

Coach

Staff member
Coach
Foundation Member
Site Immortal
Jul 17, 2003
12,636
135
63
Every trade here:


1. The Gold Coast Football Club made an offer to Restricted Free Agent Brandon Ellis (Richmond) on Friday October 4. The Richmond Football Club elected not to match the offer on Saturday October 5 and Brandon Ellis is now able to join the Gold Coast SUNS immediately.

Based on the player’s age and the contract offer, the AFL advised the Richmond Football Club the club would be eligible for a Round Two compensation selection, which would be number 39 on the current provisional draft selection order.

2. The Brisbane Lions Football Club signed Unrestricted Free Agent Cameron Ellis-Yolmen (Adelaide Crows) on Saturday October 5.

Based on the player’s age and the contract offer, the AFL advised the Adelaide Football Club the club would be eligible for a Round Three compensation selection, which would be number 49 on the current provisional draft selection order.

3. The Melbourne Football Club signed Unrestricted Free Agent Adam Tomlinson (GWS GIANTS) on Monday October 7.

Based on the player’s age and the contract offer, the AFL advised the Greater Western Sydney Football Club the club would be eligible for an End of Second Round compensation selection, which would be number 40 on the current provisional draft selection order.

4. Three-way trade on Wednesday October 9: The Geelong Cats trade Tim Kelly, its Round 3 Selection (currently number 57) and its Future Round 3 Selection to the West Coast Eagles for its Round 1 Selection (currently number 14), its Round 2 Selection (currently number 24), its Round 2 Selection (currently number 33) and its Future Round 1 Selection. The West Coast Eagles trade its Round 3 Selection (currently number 57) – on traded from Geelong Cats – to Essendon for its Round 3 Selection (currently number 52). The Geelong Cats trade its Round 2 Selection (currently number 33) – on traded from the West Coast Eagles – to Essendon for its Round 2 Selection (currently number 37).

5. The Brisbane Lions Football Club signed Unrestricted Free Agent Grant Birchall (Hawthorn) on Thursday October 10. Hawthorn Football Club received no compensation.

6. Trade on Thursday October 10: GWS GIANTS traded Round 1 selection 12 and Round 1 selection 18 to the St Kilda Football Club for Round 1 selection 6 and Round 4 selection 59.

7. Trade on Friday October 11: Melbourne Football Club traded Sam Frost, Round 3 selection 42, Round 4 selection 61 and Future Round 4 2020 selection to the Hawthorn Football Club for Round 3 selection 50 and Future Round 2 2020 selection.

8. Trade on Friday October 11: Fremantle Football Club traded Ed Langdon, Round 2 selection 26 and Future Round 4 2020 selection to Melbourne Football Club for Round 2 selection 22, Round 5 selection 79 and Future Round 2 2020 selection.

9. Trade on Friday October 11: Brisbane Lions traded Round 3 selection 46 and Round 5 selection 91 to West Coast Eagles for Round 3 selection 52 and Round 4 selection 64.

10. Trade on Monday October 14: Adelaide Crows have traded Eddie Betts to Carlton Football Club for Future Round 4 2020 selection.

11. Trade on Tuesday October 15: GWS Giants have traded Jonathon Patton to Hawthorn Football Club for Future Round 4 2020 selection (on-traded from Melbourne).

12. Trade on Tuesday October 15: Melbourne Football Club has traded Round 2 selection 26, Round 3 selection 50 and Future Round 1 2020 selection to North Melbourne Football Club for Round 1 selection 8.

13. Trade on Tuesday October 15: GWS Giants have traded Future Round 4 2020 selection to the Adelaide Crows for Sam Jacobs.

14. Trade on Tuesday October 15: Port Adelaide has traded William Frampton to the Adelaide Crows for Future Round 4 2020 selection (on traded from GWS Giants).

15. Trade on Tuesday October 15: Port Adelaide has traded Patrick Ryder, Dougal Howard, Round 1 selection 10 and Future Round 4 2020 selection to St Kilda for Round 1 selection 12, Round 1 selection 18 and Future Round 3 2020 selection.

16. Trade on Tuesday October 15: Adelaide Crows have traded Hugh Greenwood to the Gold Coast Suns for Future Round 3 2020 selection and Future Round 4 2020 selection.

17. Trade on Tuesday October 15: Sydney Swans have traded Darcy Cameron and Round 4 selection 62 to Collingwood for Round 3 selection 56.

18. Trade on Wednesday October 16: Carlton Football Club has traded Round 3 selection 48 to Sydney Swans for Round 3 selection 54 and Round 4 selection 63.

19. Trade on Wednesday October 16: Geelong Cats have traded Zac Smith to Gold Coast Suns for Round 3 selection 58.

20. Trade on Wednesday October 16: Brisbane Lions have traded Lewis Taylor to Sydney Swans for Round 3 selection 48 (on-traded from Carlton).

21. Trade on Wednesday October 16: Geelong Cats have traded Round 3 selection 58 (on-traded from Gold Coast Suns) to St Kilda Football Club for Jack Steven.

22. Trade on Wednesday October 16: Gold Coast Suns have traded Callum Ah Chee to Brisbane Lions for Future Round 2 2020 selection and Future Round 4 2020 selection.

23. Trade on Wednesday October 16: Fremantle Football Club has traded Bradley Hill and Future Round 3 2020 selection to St Kilda Football Club for Blake Acres, Round 1 selection 10 (on-traded from Port Adelaide), Round 3 selection 58 (on-traded from Geelong Cats), Future Round 2 2020 selection and Future Round 4 2020 selection.

24. Trade on Wednesday October 16: Carlton Football Club has traded Round 3 selection 54 (on-traded from Sydney Swans) and Round 4 selection 63 (on-traded from Sydney Swans) to Hawthorn Football Club for Marc Pittonet and Round 4 selection 61 (on-traded from Melbourne).

25. Trade on Wednesday October 16: Essendon Football Club has traded Round 3 selection 57 (on-traded from West Coast Eagles) and Round 4 selection 70 to Carlton Football Club for Andrew Phillips and Round 4 selection 61 (on-traded from Hawthorn) and Round 4 selection 72.

26. Trade on Wednesday October 16: St Kilda Football Club trade Josh Bruce to Western Bulldogs for Round 2 selection 32 and Round 3 selection 51.

27. Trade on Wednesday October 16: Adelaide Crows trade Alex Keath and Future Round 3 2020 selection to Western Bulldogs for Round 3 selection 45 and Future Round 2 2020 selection.

28. Trade on Wednesday October 16: Brisbane Lions trade Tom Cutler Round 4 selection 64 (on-traded from West Coast Eagles) to Essendon Football Club for Round 3 selection 72 (on-traded from Carlton) and Future Round 3 2020 selection.

29. Trade on Wednesday October 16: St Kilda Football Club trade Round 2 selection 32 (on-traded from the Western Bulldogs), Round 4 selection 76 and Future Round 3 2020 selection (on-traded from Fremantle) to Sydney Swans for Zak Jones and Round 3 selection 56 (on-traded from Collingwood) and Future Round 4 2020 selection.

30. Trade on Wednesday October 16: Richmond Football Club trade Daniel Butler to St Kilda Football Club for Round 3 selection 56 (on-traded from Sydney Swans).

31. Trade on Wednesday October 16: Adelaide Crows trade Josh Jenkins and Future Round 3 2020 selection (on-traded from Gold Coast Suns) to Geelong Cats for Round 2 selection 37 (on-traded from Essendon).

32. Trade on Wednesday October 16: GWS Giants trade Aiden Bonar and Future Round 4 2020 selection (on-traded from Melbourne) to North Melbourne Football Club for Future Round 3 2020 selection.

33. Trade on Wednesday October 16: Fremantle Football Club trade Future Round 2 2020 selection (on-traded from St Kilda) and Future Round 4 2020 selection (on-traded from St Kilda) to Collingwood Football Club for James Aish, Round 4 selection 69 and Future Round 3 2020 selection.
 

Vines

Site Immortal
Jun 9, 2008
13,585
160
63
41
We don't have to use all draft picks I don't think - we just have to make 3 list changes per year as far as I am aware.
 

honestjohn

Listed Player
Nov 25, 2011
116
32
28
57
I really don't get why Essendon was included in this trade. Sure, they received an earlier Round 2 selection but how does that help Geelong or West Coast?

Can someone explain this?
I reckon it was probably driven by West Coast. "Hey Geelong, we don't think it's fair you should have pick #33 and we are stuck with pick #57. We want a slightly higher pick. #52 will do." Forcing Geelong to drop down the pecking order a little. Small cheese I know, someone at WC had a pyrrhic victory.
 

Coach

Staff member
Coach
Foundation Member
Site Immortal
Jul 17, 2003
12,636
135
63
ADELAIDE CROWS

Traded In:

Billy Frampton
Selection No.37
Selection No.45
Selection No.49 (Ellis-Yolmen compensation)
2020 round two selection (Western Bulldogs)
2020 round four selection (Carlton)
2020 round four selection (Gold Coast)

Traded Out:
Eddie Betts
Cam Ellis-Yolmen
Hugh Greenwood
Sam Jacobs
Josh Jenkins
Alex Keath
2020 round three selection

2019 draft selections:
4, 23,28, 37, 45, 49

BRISBANE LIONS

Traded In:

Callum Ah Chee
Grant Birchall
Cam Ellis-Yolmen
Selection No.48
Selection No. 52
Selection No.72, 2020 round three selection (Essendon)

Traded Out:
Tom Cutler
Lewis Taylor
Selection No.46
Selection No.91
2020 round two selection
2020 round four selection

2019 draft selections:
16, 21, 34, 48, 52, 55, 72

CARLTON

Traded In:

Eddie Betts
Marc Pittonet
Selection No.57
Selection No.70

Traded Out:
Andrew Phillips
Selection No.48
Selection No.72
2020 round four selection

2019 draft selections:
9, 43, 57, 70, 85

COLLINGWOOD

Traded In:

Darcy Cameron
Selection No.62
2020 round two selection (St Kilda)
2020 round four selection (St Kilda)

Traded Out:
James Aish
Selection No.56
Selection No.69
2020 round three selection

2019 draft selections:
35, 62, 74

ESSENDON

Traded In:

Tom Cutler
Andew Phillips
Selection No.33
Selection No.61
Selection No.64

Traded Out:
Selection No.37
Selection No.52
Selection No.70
2020 round three selection

2019 draft selections:
31, 33, 61, 64, 65, 88

FREMANTLE

Traded In:

Blake Acres
James Aish
Selection No.10
Selection No.22
Selection No.58
Selection No.69
Selection No.79
2020 round two selection (Melbourne)
2020 round three (Collingwood)

Traded Out:
Bradley Hill
Ed Langdon
Selection No.26
2020 round three selection
2020 round four selection

2019 draft selections:
7, 10, 22, 58, 69, 79, 83

GEELONG

Traded In:

Josh Jenkins
Jack Steven
Selection No.14
Selection No.24
2020 round one selection (West Coast)
2020 round three selection (Gold Coast)

Traded Out:
Tim Kelly
Zac Smith
selection No.57
2020 round three selection

2019 draft selections:
14, 17, 24, 36, 93

GOLD COAST

Traded In:

Received AFL Assistance package – Selections 1, 20
Brandon Ellis
Hugh Greenwood
Zac Smith
2020 round two selection (Brisbane)
2020 round four selection (Brisbane)

Traded Out:
Callum Ah Chee
Selection No.58
2020 round three selection
2020 round four selection

2019 draft selections:
1, 2, 15, 20, 78, 90

GREATER WESTERN SYDNEY

Traded In:

Sam Jacobs
Selection No.6
Selection No.40 (Tomlinson compensation)
Selection No.59
2020 round three selection (North Melbourne)

Traded Out:
Aiden Bonar
Jonathon Patton
Adam Tomlinson
Selection No.12
Selection No.18
2020 round four selection

2019 draft selections:
6, 40, 59, 60, 80, 94

HAWTHORN

Traded In:

Sam Frost
Jonathon Patton
Selection No.42
Selection No.54
Selection No.63

Traded Out:
Grant Birchall
Marc Pittonet
Selection No.50
2020 round two selection

2019 draft selections:
11, 30, 42, 54, 63, 87, 92

MELBOURNE

Traded In:

Ed Langdon
Adam Tomlinson
Selection No.8
2020 round two selection (Hawthorn)
2020 round four selection (Fremantle)

Traded Out:
Sam Frost, Selection No.22, Selection No.42, Selection No.61, Selection No.79, 2020 round one Selection, 2020 round two Selection, 2020 round four Selection

2019 draft selections:
3, 8

NORTH MELBOURNE

Traded In:

Aiden Bonar
Selection No.26
Selection No.50
2020 round one selection (Melbourne)
2020 round four selection (Melbourne)

Traded Out:
Selection No.8
2020 round three selection

2019 draft selections:
26, 27, 47, 50, 73, 84

PORT ADELAIDE

Traded In:

Selection No.12
Selection No.18
2020 round three selection (St Kilda)
2020 round four Selection (GWS)

Traded Out:
Billy Frampton
Dougal Howard
Paddy Ryder
Selection No.10
2020 round four selection

2019 draft selections:
12, 18, 29, 66, 67, 68, 71, 86

RICHMOND

Traded In:

Selection No.39 (Ellis compensation)
No.56

Traded Out:
Brandon Ellis
Dan Butler

2019 draft selections:
19, 38, 39, 41, 56, 75, 77, 95

ST KILDA

Traded In:

Dan Butler
Bradley Hill
Dougal Howard
Zak Jones
Paddy Ryder
Selection No.51
2020 round four selection (Sydney)
2020 round four selection (Port Adelaide)

Traded Out:
Blake Acres
Josh Bruce
Jack Steven
Selection No.6
Selection No.59
Selection No.76
2020 round two selection
2020 round three selection
2020 round four election

2019 draft selections:
51, 82

SYDNEY

Traded In:

Lewis Taylor
Selection No.32
Selection No.76
2020 round three selection (Fremantle)

Traded Out:
Darcy Cameron
Zak Jones
Selection No.54
Selection No.62
Selection No.63
2020 round four

2019 draft selections:
5, 25, 32, 44, 76, 81

WEST COAST EAGLES

Traded In:

Tim Kelly
Selection No.46
Selection No.91
2020 round three selection (Geelong)

Traded Out:
Selection No.14
Selection No.24
Selection No.33
Selection No.64
2020 round one selection

2019 draft selections:
46, 91

WESTERN BULLDOGS

Traded In:

Josh Bruce
Alex Keath
2020 round three selection (Adelaide)

Traded Out:
Selection No.32
Selection No.45
Selection No.51
2020 round two selection

2019 draft selections:
13, 53, 89